Why Do Plantain Weeds Return?

You pull them out, spray them down, and even beg them to leave—but plantain weeds just won’t take the hint. These persistent broadleaf weeds seem to pop up overnight, especially in North Carolina lawns. At Nature’s Select®, we hear it all the time from homeowners: “Why do these things keep coming back?” Let’s dig into the reasons and, more importantly, how to stop plantain weeds for good. 

What Makes Plantain Weeds So Stubborn?

There are two types of plantain weeds common in the Carolinas: broadleaf and buckhorn. Both grow low to the ground with wide leaves that form rosettes—perfect for smothering your grass. The reason they keep coming back? Their thick taproots make them tough to pull out completely, and their seeds can survive in your soil for years, waiting for the perfect moment to sprout.

Does My Lawn Encourage Their Return?

Unfortunately, yes. Plantain weeds thrive in compacted, low-quality soil—conditions common in high-traffic areas or lawns lacking proper aeration and nutrients. If your yard has poor drainage or you mow too low, you’re basically rolling out the red carpet for these weeds.

What Actually Works to Stop Them?

A one-time spray or quick pull won’t cut it. For long-term control, a two-pronged approach is necessary: prevention and treatment. Selective broadleaf herbicides can effectively eliminate existing plantains, but the real key to success is strengthening your lawn. Aeration, proper mowing height, and fertilization all contribute to creating a thick, healthy turf that naturally crowds out weeds. That’s where a tailored lawn care program—like ours at Nature’s Select®—really makes a difference.

Can I Do This on My Own?

While DIY solutions can offer temporary relief, persistent plantain infestations typically need professional care. Our team knows exactly when and how to treat these weeds using environmentally responsible methods. We also offer crabgrass control, nutsedge control, and bluegrass control to keep your lawn looking its best from season to season.

Ready to Say Goodbye to Plantains?

You don’t have to fight the weed battle alone. At Nature’s Select®, we create custom lawn care plans that not only eliminate stubborn weeds like plantain but also enhance your soil and turf for long-lasting results. We can also help you fight off lawn insects and common diseases found throughout Greensboro, NC. Let’s give your lawn the attention it deserves. Request your free estimate at (888) 786-9735!